Why Hyderabad turned India’s surveillance capital


What began as safety considerations led to some ‘keen policing’, and finally, a police metropolis that scoffs at residents’ privateness.

This story is part of our collection on policing and excesses in Hyderabad. Learn all tales within the collection right here.

The Hyderabad Police has a doubtful distinction that it’s pleased with — it’s the twelfth most surveilled metropolis on the planet on the premise of CCTV cameras put in. In July 2020, the Telangana DGP Mahendar Reddy introduced the rating saying that town had 29.99 cameras per 1,000 individuals, a quantity that has solely gone up since to 36.52 cameras per 1,000 individuals in 2021. Based on the Bureau of Police Analysis and Authorities beneath the MHA, as of January 1, 2020, Telangana had 61% of all police CCTV cameras in India. Additional, town’s police power is known for utilizing facial recognition for a number of functions, doubtful cordon and search operations, profiling of ‘darkish, funky individuals’ for medicine, clearly unlawful telephone looking out actions, and the deceptively named ‘Operation Chabutra’. If you happen to’re residing in Hyderabad, Massive Brother is certainly watching you, whether or not you’re discussing the place to attain some ganja or just going about your life making an attempt to make a residing.

Why is Hyderabad turning right into a metropolis that activists are terming a ‘police state’? And why do you have to — an individual who has ‘nothing to cover’ — care about this?

360 diploma surveillance

It’s not simply that dissent has been curbed considerably within the state with police intervention. Telangana’s Good Governance Programme, often called Samagram, goals to combine a number of datasets to offer the state authorities a complete image of each resident — after they change jobs, all of the relationships of their life, start and dying particulars, after they get married, employment standing and extra. It does this with out the usage of Aadhaar, by integrating such databases. To reiterate — this isn’t to trace criminals alone — however to get a complete profile of each citizen.

There isn’t a lot on Telangana’s official web sites and publications about this programme. The truth is, it’s seemingly you will see that no hint of it. In a now-deleted article on Telangana Right now (thought-about to be a mouthpiece of the ruling TRS authorities), the then Police Commissioner Mahendar Reddy had stated that this mission, previously often called the Built-in Individuals Info Hub, would use information mined from police data in addition to “telephone/water/electrical energy connections, tax funds, passports, voter IDs, RTA license and registration information, e-challans and even terrorist data”. This data is later mixed with identifiers and speak to numbers to create a complete profile. One of many solely official authorities paperwork that could possibly be discovered was a presentation presumably made by the state’s IT division to the World Financial institution.

To sum up, right here’s what Telangana’s IT Secretary stated in 2019 on how an individual’s digital footprint is used: “We have now created a finest algorithm via which this machine studying capabilities has grow to be so sturdy that right now we’ve reached a stage of virtually 96-97% accuracy. So when you inform me one particular person’s identify I can provide his complete digital footprint at about 96% accuracy to them… this instrument throws up the leads to a matter of seconds and the instrument additionally may be very helpful in doing what is known as household tree evaluation or relationship evaluation.”

In current day, the Hyderabad police has continually termed itself to be people-friendly, likening itself to the New York Metropolis Police Division (NYPD). The upcoming Command and Management Centre in Hyderabad was additionally initially impressed by the 1 Police Plaza of the NYPD in Manhattan.

Policing and governance are intertwined, and for this, Telangana has tied up with the European nation of Estonia to take a look at implementing its X Street Platform in Telangana with applicable Indian modifications. X Street permits non-public and public information to be shared securely between departments, just like the Samagram system. Nevertheless, whereas information safety in Estonia is ruled by the EU’s Common Knowledge Safety Regulation (GDPR) guidelines, India doesn’t have a private information safety legislation as but.

Although Samagram was constructed after Telangana was shaped in 2014 and when the TRS got here to energy, Hyderabad’s fixation with policing its residents began a lot earlier, in line with Srinivas Kodali, who works with the Free Software program Motion of India, and has been monitoring the developments with regard to policing.

How did Hyderabad get right here

It began with the phobia assaults in Hyderabad, when it was a part of undivided Andhra Pradesh, and in different elements of India within the mid to late 2000s, in line with Srinivas. He’s referring to the August 2007 blasts in Lumbini Amusement Park and Gokul Chat Bhandar that killed not less than 42 individuals, and to the Mumbai terror assaults of 2008, the place 12 coordinated shootings killed not less than 145 individuals. CCTV use in Hyderabad went up after the 2007 blasts within the metropolis, Srinivas says, and a legislation was then handed in 2013 to amend the Public Security Act that required all institutions with a gathering of greater than 100 individuals to put in CCTV cameras and switch over the footage to an Inspector as required.

“Numerous the early experimentation additionally occurred in Hyderabad as a result of our police had been keen,” Srinivas says.

A surveillance state?

What began with CCTV cameras for public security is now bordering on Hyderabad changing into a surveillance state. Facial recognition has grow to be a typical fixture, and has been acknowledged to have been used for quite a few issues: monitoring lacking individuals, retaining observe of offenders, individuals believed to be suspects, authenticating pension information beneath MeeSeva, RTA providers, e-voting experiments, on the airport, in addition to the state fee for larger training. It has additionally been proposed to be launched for the Public Distribution System to obtain ration. This even supposing counting on facial recognition alone has been proven to be unreliable.

There have been a number of different actions that the Hyderabad police has carried out beneath the garb of “individuals pleasant policing” — stopping individuals and checking WhatsApp chats for ‘medicine’, profiling individuals they consider are junkies, in addition to randomly halting and taking individuals’s fingerprints, images and Aadhaar numbers and feeding them right into a database, the Central Felony Monitoring Community and Methods (CCTNS). The final one, named Operation Chabutra, has been a fixture of the police since 2015 — and has since solely grown in dimension. It’s meant to, of their phrases, deter youth from roaming round at evening — and whether or not or not that is authorized is questionable at finest, as the info that’s collected is matched in opposition to current data within the system for pending warrants or legal data.

The police’s crown jewel, nonetheless, are cordon and search operations, the place areas are illegally cordoned off and searched. The police declare its objective is to instill confidence in native communities, however is principally carried out in areas the place individuals from low earnings teams or minority communities reside in worry and mistrust among the many people who find themselves focused. An space is picked, after which 100-150 members of the police power then go right into a colony and verify car paperwork, identification proofs, and whether or not they have liquor or ganja.

Cordon and searches has been termed a human rights violation by the Workplace of the United Nations Excessive Commissioner for Human Rights, however has been prevalent not less than since 2013 within the metropolis, beginning with the Cyberabad commissionerate.

Learn: Army tactic on civilians: A deep dive into Hyderabad cops’ cordon and search ops

Cordon and search operations, Srinivas says, return to when anti-Naxal operations had been carried out in united Andhra Pradesh.

The insurgency in Andhra Pradesh started within the Sixties, across the identical time that the Naxalbari rebellion happened, sparking an identical peasant rebellion in Srikakulam. Within the Seventies, it unfold to districts like erstwhile Karimnagar and Adilabad in Telangana area as properly. With the formation of the Individuals’s Warfare Group (PWG), the motion gained additional traction. Naxals had been lively even within the early 2000s, however now their actions are relegated to the forests between Telangana, Andhra Pradesh, Odisha and Chattisgarh. Within the Eighties and Nineteen Nineties, the Hindu reported {that a} technique of the police was to rely closely on cordon and search operations. It was discovered to be futile then.

Hyderabad MP and AIMIM chief Asaduddin Owaisi tells TNM that in precept, the police can cease individuals and verify car paperwork, search and so on. “However they can’t go right into a locality, knock on individuals’s doorways after which ask for Aadhaar particulars, take images, fingerprints, verify telephones, and so on. All that is a part of private privateness. Underneath what legislation is that this being completed? It needs to be specified,” he stated.

He says that Operation Chabutra has been stopped, however with regard to information assortment by the police, he questions what’s the assure that it’ll not be misused. “We don’t understand how secure police information is.”

Why do you have to care?

Whereas individuals could say that they don’t have anything to cover and therefore don’t thoughts being checked or questioned, it’s a slender and maybe even handy argument provided by people and establishments who want to violate privateness, says Vidushi Marda, a senior programme officer at human rights organisation Article 19 who investigates the results of integrating synthetic intelligence methods in societies. On the identical time, there’s a tendency to make an incorrect and inappropriate ethical judgment about privateness being the identical as secrecy, she provides.

“Privateness empowers us to determine what data we open up to others, when and the way. It will be important for particular person autonomy, it kinds the premise of our potential to develop our voice, to construct relationships with others. To cut back it to a proper that one ought to solely care about if one has one thing to cover, is an lively and deliberate try and dilute it to its most slender kind,” she says.

She provides that such policing not solely blatantly violates basic rights, however “additionally normalises and entrenches the observe of the police appearing with impunity, making up practices and guidelines as they go as a substitute of grounding them in legislation and due course of.”

She stresses that it’s essential to have a dialog about how the Structure “merely affirms rights that people have, as a limitation on state energy”, and that the rights of residents will not be offered for by the state.

Profiling and policing in low earnings areas represents the tendency to embed arbitrariness into policing practices, she says, including that it’s a slippery slope.

You will need to be aware that India doesn’t have a knowledge safety legislation, and the reworked report is more likely to be introduced within the ongoing session of Parliament. It won’t, nonetheless, resolve the basic problems with discriminatory policing and authorities overreach, says Vidushi.

“Within the absence of a knowledge safety legislation, the federal government is ready to act carte blanche on what information is collected, shared, saved and analysed within the absence of any accountability mechanisms. ‘New’ or ‘fancy’ applied sciences appear to get pleasure from an unjustified exceptionalism to well-established constitutional rules, which solely endanger our rights extra,” she says.


Telangana has the biggest variety of facial recognition tasks in India

Additionally learn:

Solely 7 of 60 Hyderabad police stations reveal information on cordon and search operations

Funky haircuts or sneakers, lean physique: Hyderabad police’s profile of a ‘junkie’


Supply hyperlink